Just Add Water

Shorefront homes retain their value.

text by: Joan Tapper

June 1, 2007

Headlines, real estate surveys, personal anecdotes…the evidence seems to indicate that the heady boom times in real estate are over. A recent study by the National Association of Realtors, for ex-ample, found falling prices and slowing home sales in more than half of the nation’s largest metropolitan areas in the last quarter of 2006. However, when it comes to specific segments of specific markets, the picture is a lot more complex.

"The years 2004 and 2005 were catch-up and windfall years," says Michael Saunders of Michael Saunders & Company, which is based in Sarasota, one of the areas targeted by the Realtors’ group study. "Then 2006 was the beginning of a normal market, and you needed to price accordingly. It was a challenging year in Florida in general. But waterfront homes remained strong."


Despite recent dips in real estate prices, waterfront homes and residential communities, such as the new Ritz-Carlton Kapalua development, have held their value. (Click image to enlarge)

From Florida to South Carolina, from California’s Central Coast to Seattle and beyond to Hawaii, Realtors who handle luxury waterfront properties—both single-family homes and condominiums—present a nuanced view of the state of real estate. The finest properties, especially in waterfront communities, they say, have held their own. And not surprisingly, they articulate the same classic principles: Long-term luxury real estate investors who want to live in their homes will be rewarded; speculators in a market with oversupply will not fare so well.


When finished in December 2007, Kapalua will offer villas, condo-hotel units and fractional residences on Maui’s north shore. (Click image to enlarge)


Florida
"I have a golden three-year rule," Saunders says. "If someone bought three years ago, I challenge anyone to show me how they lost money." She estimates that prices on waterfront properties have adjusted downward 10 to 12 percent over the previous year, but notes that the top five sales in the Sarasota area were for waterfront and ranged from $9 million to $13 million.

And there is tremendous variety in Sarasota’s upper-end market. "Between Tampa and Sarasota, you have a string of barrier islands," she says, "each offering both gulfshore, with sandy beaches, and bayfront, with protected, deep water. For a single-family home, the top of the market is around $18 million, but you could look in the $8 million range and find something special. You also have rivers, with broad, tranquil water with direct access to the gulf. For something more urban, there are condos in downtown Sarasota, and also on Longboat Key."

Upscale condos—typically a 4,000-square-foot unit with direct waterfront—would be in the $3 million to $4 million range, she notes. Saunders is handling a three-bedroom penthouse condominium on Longboat Key, for example, with 10-foot ceilings, terrace, gourmet kitchen and sunset water views, listed at $3.6 million.


Just north of Miami, Bal Harbour has attracted upscale developments like the St. Regis Resort & Residences. (Click image to enlarge)

Chad Roffers, of Sky Sotheby’s International Realty (also in Sarasota), says that since early 2007 sales have been strong and prices have stabilized at about the levels of the end of 2004. Products not previously in vogue are coming back, he adds. "In the bull market there were new developments—golf courses, downtown properties and gated communities. Now the tried-and-true beach- and bayfront are moving." Roffers points to both Longboat and Siesta Key as great opportunities. "Buyers have never had this much choice." For instance, he has listed a four-bedroom, 7,500-square-foot, two-story bayfront home in the Country Club Shores area of Longboat Key at $4.29 million.

Resources

Michael Saunders & Company, An Exclusive Affiliate of Christie’s Great Estates
888.552.5228, www.michaelsaunders.com

Sky Sotheby’s International Realty
941.366.9777, www.skysothebysrealty.com

Premier Properties of Southwest Florida, Inc. Realtors, An Exclusive Affiliate of Christie’s Great Estates
800.523.3346, www.premier-properties.com

Sol Sotheby’s International Realty
305.573.4700, www.solsothebys.com

St. Regis Resort & Residences, Bal Harbour
888.278.0056, www.stregisresidences.com/balharbour

One Thousand Ocean Beach Villas & Residences at the Boca Raton Resort
561.869.5000, www.onethousandocean.com

Celia Dunn, Sotheby’s International Realty
888.810.0143, www.celiadunnsir.com

Ewing & Clark
206.322.2840, www.ewingandclark.com

Monterey Peninsula Sotheby’s International Realty
831.624.1566, www.mpsir.com

Kitty Hughes, Madison House
206.726.5277, www.madisonhouseltd.com

Cathy George & Associates
808.373.9844, www.cgahawaii.com

Mary Worrall Associates, Sotheby’s International Realty
808.735.4211, www.worrall.com

Elena Roud, Prudential Locations
808.224.7274, www.prudentiallocations.com

The Residences at Kapalua Bay
800.281.9440, www.kapaluabay.com

The Residential Suites at the Ritz-Carlton Kapalua
877.559.3999, www.livingkapalua.com

Honua Kai
866.678.1310, www.honuakai.com



Subscribe Today

BONUS: Pay now and receive two free issues! RISK FREE TRIAL ISSUE Subscribe today and get a free issue. If you like it, you'll pay $19.97 for 5 more issues (6 in all). If not, write "cancel" on the invoice you receive, the free issue is yours to keep.